The editors of the Science Fiction Book Club has included Robert A. Heinlein’s “Stranger in a Strange Land” to its list of the top 50 most important science fiction/fantasy works of all time. It was fourth on the list, behind (1.) J.R.R. Tolkien’ “Lord of the Rings”; (2.) Isaac Asimov’s “Foundation Trilogy”; and (3.) Frank Herbert’s “Dune.”
According to a press release:
Ellen Asher, Science Fiction Book Club Senior Editor, described Heinlein, author of “Stranger in a Strange Land,”; as “the single most popular and widest-read science fiction writer of all time. ‘Stranger’; was not only a phenomenon for science fiction readers. It jumped the borders into the wider culture, giving a new lexicon to the late ’60s and a new way of looking at the world.”
USA Today reporter Bob Minzesheimer chose a more sarcastic description:
Robert A. Heinlein’s “Stranger in a Strange Land”; (1961) features a child from Mars who adapts to life on Earth and founds his own church, which resembles a swinger”s club.
Heinlein’s “Starship Troopers” was listed as 46th on the full list, while Joe Haldeman’s “The Forever War” sort of a liberal’s version of “SST” was 24th on the list while Heinlein’s “The Moon is a Harsh Mistress” didn’t make the list at all.
Did Heinlein get the respect he was due in this list? Well, you can’t really complain about finishing fourth. And as much as I love and respect Heinlein’s work, Tolkein’s masterpiece is much more influential. I like Asimov’s work, too. I think his Robot novels were more influential than the Foundation novels (although he later merged them into the same universe). I could never get past the first few pages of “Dune.”
I also would have included L. Neil Smith’s “The Probability Broach” and Spider Robinson’s “Callahan’s Crosstime Saloon.”
UPDATE: All complaints, criticisms and insults directed at this list concerning numbers 11-50 are invalid. It was just pointed out to me that except for the top 10, the books are listed in alphabetical order. In my defense, there is no explanation of this anywhere on the site, and it took someone with a better eye for detail than I to catch it.